Pulling car out garage issues

Issue: Stored my car in my personal garage. Tried pulling it out and it pulled out a stock Jester, different license plate, no keys to the car. My friend doesnt see the car but I do

Steps
1. Put Jester in garage
2. Pull Jester out garage
3. Can keep pulling out as many jesters as I want lol
4. Open local Jester car shop (Joke)

Whats suppose to happen:
When I pull my car out, it should be my car

https://www.twitch.tv/videos/1899680745